I’ve read about many issues pertaining
to education and how they affect students. Today, the issue that has captured my attention is the discrepancy in
the income of student’s families, and how this plays a role in their attendance.
As
a teacher myself, I know the
importance of regular attendance, and the consequences that can result from perpetual absences.
Low-income households have more
chronic absences, because of
hardships financially on the family and other factors that stem from the lesser
income.
According to the National Center for
Education Statistics, there were 98,817 public schools during the 2009-2010 school year located within
the United States (Balfanz, Chang). Some of these
public schools are found in districts that have many people that are impoverished, while other districts have very wealthy people in the districts.
So
there is clearly a large discrepancy in the amount of money given to schools
for all the things that they need. There are students
in these schools that are absent many times throughout the year, these are referred to as chronic absences.
This
occurs when a student misses 10
percent or more of the school year, or in the previous year missed a
month or more of school (Balfanz, Byrnes 3). Students within the lower income school districts generally miss
more school for various reasons such as economic factors or family reasons.
Income
inequality in schools greatly affects attendance, as those who do not have as great an income are at risk for
chronic absences and therefore development issues.
These attendance issues are not normally caught by
schools, because they do not have the funds
to track student attendance for the school year. As
with my own school, most schools observe daily
attendance or if a student is absent for a couple days in a row,
then they will check on that student. The
problem with this system is that “it takes just two
days a month to reach 18 days, or 10% of the school year” (Balfanz, Chang).
When
students miss 10% or more of school per year, this places those students substantially further behind the
rest of the class. School
attendance is by far the strongest predictor of course performance. There was a study done that
observed and analyzed student absences and how that affected student’s grades. This study concluded,
“that even moderate amounts of absenteeism had strong impacts. Students with high test scores
who missed two or more weeks of school per semester were more likely to fail
than students with low test scores who missed a week or less of school” (Balfanz,
Byrnes 25). Being
in school is extremely important for students and their well-being. Students who are not regularly
attending school become at risk for falling behind their peers. It has been proven that even “children
from low-income families with good attendance…gained more literacy skills than
peers from higher-income families during kindergarten and first grade” (Balfanz,
Byrnes 23). It is crucial for students to
attend class, as this will help their overall
education.
Students who do not regularly attend class become at risk for having to
repeat the grade, if they do not learn the skills
necessary to pass.
As a teacher, it is difficult to watch
students struggle because they cannot make it to class.
Low-income students have many reasons
for missing classes throughout the school year. According to the
National Association of Secondary School Principals there are some categories
that they use to explain absences:
We use three
categories to explain absences: discretion, aversion, and barriers.
With
discretion, parents and
students don’t understand how much attendance matters, schools lack a strong culture of attendance, or students simply have something else they would rather do.
With
aversion, a child could be
struggling academically, victimized by
bullying, or dealing
with anxiety. And with barriers, students lack access to healthcare; have no safe path to
school; lack effective transportation options; or face family responsibilities, housing instability, a need to work, or are caught up
in the juvenile justice system. (Balfanz, Chang).
These reasons for not showing up to school can affect any child
in America. It is not just low-income or high-income students that these
affect. Parents who are scheduled to work a night or late shift at their
job often return home exhausted. As a result, they are unable to
get up to take their child to school in the morning.
These
absences add up, and can contribute
to a child’s chronic absentee rate. The category that
affects low-income students more than other students is the barriers.
Some
of these students, even ones that I
have observed, do not have health
insurance or families that can afford it. As a result, these students become sick and stay sick for a longer period of
time. Some students are living in rough neighborhoods because that is
the only district where their parents could afford to buy a home.
If
the student if older, that student also
might have to get a job in order to help provide for the family.
However, a higher-income student home would not necessarily need a
student to start and keep a job to help pay the bills.
These
students have many different issues outside of the classroom that can affect
them, as well as those
problems going on inside the school such as bullying and not feeling like being
at school matters. Students who are bullied do not want to attend school for fear
that they will be teased, ridiculed, or even assaulted. Due to an increase in
bullying within schools, student absentee
rates have been growing. It is important to recognize these issues
that students face, and equip them
with the means necessary to be able to attend school regularly while facing
these challenges. Missing classes greatly affects students grades and test scores, placing them farther behind their higher income peers.
Ultimately, income inequality has an impact on student attendance in
schools. The studies have shown that students who show
up to class on a regular basis do better in class than those who have a history
of being absent. Financial problems cause many students to
have to start a job early in life to help pay the bills for the family. Many other factors play
roles in student academic achievement, but it begins with attendance.
Work
Cited
Balfanz, Robert,
and Vaughan Byrnes. The Importance of Being in School: A Report on
Absenteeism in the Nations Public Schools. Rep. Getschooled.com, May 2012.
Web. 17 Nov. 2014.
Balfanz, Robert,
and Hedy Chang. "Content." A Focus on Attendance Is Key to Success.
N.p., n.d. Web. 17 Nov. 2014.
This specific topic was very interesting to me. Being a future teacher myself, I am fully aware of how important attendance is. It is the essential in learning, obviously the student cannot learn without being present. Attendance is something that can be affected by many factors as you mentioned. Some of the things you mentioned I have correlated with attendance, but others I never thought of. For example, I never put into perspective that some students may be missing school because they need to work for the family. Especially in some cultures, working is sometimes looked at as a demand or more important than education. Low income students also suffer from parents who may not be able to take them to school because they are working. I really enjoyed reading this simply because it allows others to see that sometimes lack of attendance isn't simply laziness but there are other factors that contribute to it. Overall, I learned the reality of students who come from low income families and the obstacles they go through with something as simple as attendance. -Erika Smith
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading your article. I like that you were able to relate it your profession. I think that it is extremely sad and heartbreaking that children do not attend school on a daily basis. This interests me because I am a parent and my children are not too far from being enrolled in school. I wasn't aware that reasons for the children missing schools are placed into three categories called barriers, aversion, and discretion. Erika Smith wrote a similar article to the one above. She also mentions that teachers and schools can also be a factor to why children miss class. She stated that the school may not have the resources. Also, that the teacher may not seem enthusiastic. I have had a few teachers myself that seem like they do not care. They teach very little or have the class read the chapter to the class, give the class a test and grade the test. To me there is no teacher there other than the students. If a student sees that the teacher is lazy and does not want to teach, they may feel lazy as well and may not want to learn. She also mentioned that 1/3 of students do not receive their high school diploma. This is a huge number! Most employers want an Associates degree at minimum and if they want to move up then, the employer would want a bachelors or a masters. So if the students cannot even gain a high school diploma then, how will they get anywhere in life? They will stay at a dead end job not moving up. Children do not even have neighborhood schools anymore. They have to travel further to another school in another neighborhood. In Chicago, they were supposed to have safe passages but that only lasted for a week or two and that was it. Sure, they signs are up but there are not police anywhere. Maybe if they weren't sitting at desks or just driving around they would be helping children feel safe with just their appearance at and around the schools. This could solve at least one problem and increase the number in the amount of children going to school.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your blog. It was an interesting and important topic. Attendance is crucial to not fall behind in class, I know from personal experience. Even missing one class, you miss a lot of learning that usually carries over to next class. So not only did you miss that lesson but if you are in class the next day, you are going to be kind of lost. I did not realize however that there were three different classifications with school absentees, discretion, aversion, and barriers that is interesting to me. I thought an absence was just an absence. I agree with you that there should be a way to track chronic absences, not to get the student in trouble but to find out the root of the problem so maybe there can be some help. For example, the child that doesn't have a ride to or from school, the school should provide bussing to help even if they are out of zone for free bussing.
ReplyDeleteWhen considering why students from low-income families are more prone to chronic absences, would students from high-income families do the same, but for different reasons? Chronic absences as defined in the article say that students who miss 10% or more of the school year are considered chronically absent. Would it be possible then, for students from high-income families to be chronically absent due to high-income family activities like vacations, trips or plain laziness, stemming from the fact that their parents can fund them for the rest of their life?
ReplyDeleteAlso, the article says that “School attendance is by far the strongest predictor of course performance”, but I simply do not agree. In my school, I’ve seen plenty of students miss school for more than that 10% mark, but their performance in school is still above average. The strongest predictor for course performance is not attendance, but I believe that it is up to the individual’s drive to be successful. Many students can miss school for reasons that they cannot control, but what they do after the fact is what matters. What students can do if they have to miss school for personal reasons is that they can contact their teacher outside of school in order to do make-up work, perhaps even talking about why they cannot show up for school but make up for it by doing the work at home. To a teacher, that will show that they are taking the initiative over their school-work and success.
When students miss school because parents are not able to get up and take them to school, where is the public transportation at? Are school buses not set up and scheduled to pick up the vast majority of students within the area? At my high-school, the only kids that needed to be driven to school would be the ones that lived within a mile of school property. I can see a problem though, where walking a mile everyday just to go to school might be demotivating to some.
As bullying and other threats to students arise in this age, more aversion is happening in schools, and that will definitely demotivate students from going to school. Bullying is a factor that many parents do not want to happen to their kids, but it happens anyways. Until confronted by their parents about it, students will never speak up about it to their parents. Instead, fear overcomes the student and threats fall on deaf ears.
I agree that attendance is a vital role in student success, but I do not believe that it plays the core role in student success. I believe that student success is made by the students themselves, believing that they can complete school and get a degree and move forward in their lives. Students have to take the initiative, but that comes from the parents being able to set their kids up for success.
agree with where Christian is coming from on low income families. Missing school repetively greatly affects their chance to graduate and to perform well in school. In particular it reminds me of a student who goes to Walther Christian Academy and is absent quite a bit, but not because of his own fault. His family missed tuition payments due to his family being poor and even though I can tell he loves being at school he can't. Of course, Walther is a private school so it's a bit harder to just let him go to school anyways and Walther is a great school for students that may live in bad areas. I wish students could be home schooled if they are put into these types of situations, but usually their parents both work and/or don't have the education to home school their child. It would be interesting to see teachers utilize videos to help students who are absent a lot like with some teachers using Khan Academy videos for their class (for math) and Khan Academy is free for everyone with practice problems too.
ReplyDeleteI found this post interesting and easy to relate to. I attended a community high school in a low-income neighborhood. About 90% of the students there received free-reduced lunch. I personally knew couple of people that were absent quite a lot or had to leave early in order to get to work on time. And of course that this affected their learning, I also agree that attendance is crucial when it comes to one's education. However, at my school the students talked to the professors and sometimes they were not marked as absent. This was because then they would be suspended or even kicked out due to their lack of attendance. Also, I think that the professors also did it in part because they knew that the kids had no choice. If they wanted food on their table and a roof they had to go to work to help their parents out. I find this saddening because most of the kids loved school but could not fully enjoy it.
ReplyDelete